European Union declared ‘LGBTIQ Freedom Zone’ but reality is quite different

On 11 March 2021, the European Parliament passed a resolution declaring the European Union a ‘LGBTIQ Freedom Zone‘. This resolution was a reaction to self-declared LGBT-free and ‘LGBT-ideology’ free zones in Poland and Hungary. But ILGA-Europe made a state of the European Union regarding the real-life situation of queer people in the EU.

The International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia and Transphobia (IDAHOT) is less than a month away. 17 May. 

“Across the EU, we are witnessing a stark rise of hate against LGBTI people”, ILGA-Europe writes

“In our recently published ‘Annual Review 2021‘, we reported an increase of hate speech from political, religious leaders and on social media in several countries of the region. Additionally, the COVID-19 crisis has made vulnerable communities even more vulnerable.

It’s not only in Poland and Hungary that LGBTI people and communities need protection. 

Earlier in March, a gay man was murdered in Beveren, near Antwerp in Belgium, having been lured via a dating app to a park, where he was attacked by three teenagers. 

Flags of the European Union, Belgium, Flanders and the Province of Antwerp.

Love is love? 

Reaction in Belgium, in Flanders in particular, was overwhelming. Politics and public denounced this atrocious attack. ‘Love is love’, people hashtagged. It is true there’s all too often violence against same-sex couples. Displaying same-sex romantic affection publicly is a coming-out. And unfortunately, some react violently to that.

But with David Polfliet in Beveren that wasn’t the case. Friends testified he was single. David wanted to have sex. Coronavirus countermeasures closed safe spaces for LGBTQI people to meet and/or to have sex. So David turned to the apps. He got mugged and that ended fatally. 

‘Love is love’ is a generic anti-homophobic slogan. But in this case it wasn’t appropriate. LGBTQI activism in Belgium is very couples and families oriented. Same-sex family recognition, the right to adopt, in vitro fertilisation (IVF), surrogacy. 

On television, gay people have a monogamous relationship. You hardly ever see a gay single on television. Said gay couples never see other queer people. There’s only room for the nucleus of queer families. Same-sex couple, preferably with adopted or foster children. 

According to the European Men-Who-Have-Sex-With-Men Internet Survey (EMIS-2017), 54% of gay and bi men are single. But – in Belgium at least – LGBTQI activism prefers the Disney version of reality, where boy meets boy and they lived happily ever after “without needing to be outspoken gay”. 

Rainbow, stylized Mickey Mouse.

LGBTIQ Freedom Zone

Back to the assessment of Queer Europe. 

“Declaring the EU an LGBTIQ Freedom Zone is not enough: this strong statement must be followed by actions that bring real change to LGBTI people and communities in the region”, ILGA-Europe says.

Overview of countries

Austria: “There is no protection against hate speech or hate crimes based on gender expression, gender identity and sexual characteristics.”

Belgium: Hate and violence are on the rise. A gay man was brutally murdered on March 6 in Beveren. Three teenagers allegedly stabbed him to death after luring him into a fake date arranged on a dating app.”

Bulgaria: “Children of a same-sex couple can lose one parent just by crossing an EU border. A child of a same-sex couple is currently at risk of statelessness as Bulgarian authorities have not recognised the baby’s valid EU birth certificate.

Croatia: “There is an increase of hate speech and violence. In February 2020, an effigy of two men kissing and a child was burnt at a festival, weeks after the country’s highest court ruled that same-sex couples could become foster parents.”

Cyprus: “The reform of legal gender recognition has been stalling for years now.”

Czechia: “Sterilisation is required to access legal gender recognition. A case law from the European Court of Human Rights on the matter has been waiting for years now to be implemented.”

Denmark: “The country failed to ban unnecessary surgeries and treatment on intersex infants and minors, despite multiple United Nations’ recommendations.”

Estonia: “Attacks on civil society have increased. Despite recommendations from the UN Human Rights Committee in 2019, no progress has been made to include sexual orientation and gender identity in the hate speech and hate crime legislation.”

Finland: “Trans people are required to be sterilised before accessing legal gender recognition.”

France: “The number of hate crimes against LGBTI people increased in 2020, for a fourth consecutive year, according to SOS Homophobie. Two LGBTI children, who were bullied at their schools, committed suicide.”

Germany : “Same-sex couples cannot adopt. Legal gender recognition legislation is outdated and its reform has been stalling for years.”

Greece: “The latest amendments to immigration legislation have restricted the rights of LGBTI asylum seekers. In January 2020, a booklet was distributed by the Church in the Athens Holargos high school, saying that being homosexual is a ‘hateful act’ and that LGBTI people were ‘traitors’ and ‘murderers’.

Hungary: “The Hungarian Parliament banned legal gender recognition in May 2020. The following December, it also voted to abolish the Equal Treatment Authority, Hungary’s most important equality body. Bookshops selling the children’s book ‘Wonderful is for Everyone‘, which depicted diverse families and characters, were labelled as promoters of homosexuality and their staff were threatened. Prime Minister Viktor Orbán commented on the book saying that homosexuals should ‘leave our kids alone’.”

Ireland: “The country witnessed deeply worrying cases of hate crime and violence. A young gay couple was beaten up and stubbed in Kildare in February 2020. In September, a video on social media showed ten students from a Dublin private school verbally assaulting a classmate who had recently come out.”

Italy: “There is no legal protection against discrimination outside the labour market on the grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity.”

Latvia: “In January 2021, the Latvian Parliament started examination of the constitutional amendment seeking to restrict the extension of the concept the concept of family. The country does not recognise same-sex partnerships and still requires trans people to be sterilised before having access to legal gender recognition.”

Lithuania: “Partnership is not recognised. Politician and LGBT rights activist, Tomas Vytautas Raskevičius (Liberty Party) secured a seat in parliament during the autumn elections. When he wanted to be chair of the human rights committee, he was received with homophobic hate and threats.

Luxembourg: “In July 2020, the town of Esch-sur-Alzette announced it would prohibit shared flats if those cohabiting are not relatives or partners, which would forcefully out many same-sex couples and could be used in a discriminatory manner.

Malta: “The Equality Act has not been implemented yet.”

Flag of Malta.

Netherlands: “Schools have the right to ask parents to sign a statement rejecting a homosexual lifestyle, as long as the school ensures a safe environment for all pupils. During the summer, over 60 cases of discrimination and violence against LGBTIQ asylum seekers were reported.”

Poland: “In Poland, over 100 towns have declared themselves ‘LGBT-free zones’. Officially led hate speech and scapegoating of LGBTI people continue to be on the rise. In August 2020, 48 people protesting the detention of LGBTI activist Margot Szutowicz were also arrested. Partnerships are not recognised.”

Portugal: “There is no legal protection against discrimination outside the labour market on the grounds of sexual orientation and gender identity.

Romania: “The Court of Justice of the European Union judgement in the Coman case, which three years ago established that same-sex spouses are fully recognised as spouses under the EU freedom of movement directive, has to this day not been enacted by the Romanian state, and the partner of Adrian Coman still has not been granted a residence permit in Romania, leaving other same-sex couples in similar situations in limbo. There is no partnership recognition and trans people are still required to be sterilised before having access to legal gender recognition.”

Slovakia: “The country still requires trans people to be sterilised before having access to legal gender recognition.”

Slovenia: “Non-governmental organisations in Slovenia are increasingly targeted by the government’s restrictive measures and hostile rhetoric. Leading the government, the radical right Slovenian Democratic Party and PM Janez Janša direct their hostility especially towards NGOs engaged in independent cultural production and defending human rights, media freedom and the environment.”

Spain: There are very harmful debates at the moment around the Trans Law. A group of trans people and their families are on hunger strike since March 2021. They will continue until the proposed legislation is debated at the Spanish House of Representatives.”

Flag of Spain, in the middle.

Sweden: “At the initiative of the right wing populist party Sweden Democrats, the municipality of Hörby put forward a new policy banning raising the rainbow flag on municipal flagpoles. The local church responded by displaying the rainbow flag on their flagpole. The policy was later withdrawn, but follows a similar and successful ban passed in 2019 in Sölvesborg.”

Related posts

17 Comments Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s